Maandag 06/02/2023


Belgium is No Failed State

Het metrostation van Maalbeek één dag na de aanslag. Beeld Photo News
Het metrostation van Maalbeek één dag na de aanslag.Beeld Photo News

Sir Michael Leigh is voormalig directeur-generaal voor de uitbreiding bij de Europese Commissie en senior fellow bij het German Marshall Fund of the United States. Hij publiceerde dit opiniestuk oorspronkelijk op

Sir Michael Leigh

Belgium has come in for intense criticism following the deadly Brussels airport and metro attacks on 22 March that left 32 people dead and many more wounded. Commentators have labelled Belgium a "dysfunctional divided country," "an incubator of terror," and "a country that operates on the basis of "linguistic apartheid." Some have even likened Belgium to Syria and Iraq as failed states.

But it is simplistic to blame Belgium for Europe's vulnerability to terrorism. Every major security failure from Pearl Harbor to 9/11 and the Paris attacks last November has been followed by revelations of warnings that were ignored and of raw intelligence that was not evaluated in a timely and effective manner.

The NSA, CIA and FBI were alerted before the 9/11 attacks but the terrorists slipped through their fingers. The 9/11 Commission report showed that the different jurisdictions of law enforcement authorities in New York City and across the US made coordination difficult. Despite tip offs, the British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher narrowly escaped with her life when the IRA bombed the Conservative Party conference in 1984.

Belgian leaders acknowledge the shortcomings that preceded the Brussels attacks. Two ministers offered their resignations and the government rushed through overdue legislation to permit round-the-clock house searches, limit arms sales, and create a single counter-terrorism data base. There have been calls to increase resources for social inclusion and counter-radicalization programs in the Brussels municipality of Molenbeek and other deprived areas.

The French urban affairs minister Patrick Kanner has commented that France has around 100 municipalities with potential similarities to Molenbeek. In France these are mostly isolated suburban neighborhoods where amenities are inadequate and violence is widespread. In Belgium immigrant-based communities live in the cities themselves and are politically represented. Many members of Belgian regional parliaments have immigrant backgrounds.

Just the same, poorer municipalities in Brussels need better playgrounds, schools, youth clubs and other social facilities; local communities must play their part in ensuring that such facilities are maintained. Additional resources are needed both to give the Muslim population a stake in Belgian society and to ensure more effective policing. But resources are scarce. Besides its immigrants, Brussels hosts a large international presence, including the EU, NATO, three diplomatic communities, and some 2,000 international bodies, as well as thousands of ex-pats. Many of these bodies are tax exempt and commuters pay tax in the areas outside Brussels where they live.

Despite Belgium's multi-level system of governance, the country does better than many European states in rankings of the quality of justice, income equality, and perceptions of corruption. Belgium's "linguistic wars" have rarely degenerated into violence. The country has remained stable during the prolonged negotiations that often precede the formation of new governments. Belgium has evolved from a unitary state to a highly decentralized federal state, while preserving sufficient consensus to maintain social peace.

Despite the growth of anti-EU, anti-immigrant political movements, as elsewhere in Europe, Belgians on the whole remain firm advocates of a federal Europe. Following the Brussels attacks, many Belgians sympathized with the call by Jean-Claude Juncker, the European Commission President, for a European "security union."

Yet kneejerk calls for "more Europe" do not necessarily produce results in the 28-member European Union, where perceptions of national interest vary considerably. The EU lacks legal powers in the fields of intelligence and security, which are essentially the preserve of national authorities. In fighting terrorism, Belgian intelligence services need to cooperate with the CIA and Mossad as much as with the DGSE in France or the BND in Germany. However, where "Europe" has acquired real responsibilities, as with the Schengen Information System, Europol, or the "European arrest warrant", they should be reinforced and used to the full.

Belgium cannot prevent terrorism through an "escape into Europe." But it can achieve much by improving coordination between the federal, regional and local levels and by renegotiating their respective responsibilities. Nineteen separate municipalities and six separate police forces are too many for a capital region of just over 1 million inhabitants. Despite linguistic sensitivities, the municipalities should accept greater coordination at regional and federal level while local authorities should be informed of investigations underway and of the identity of inhabitants who have returned from Syria or Iraq. Recently a trilingual citizens' petition demanded that a single metropolitan police force be set up, giving further proof of the vibrancy of the city's civil society.

For half a century Belgium has made a major contribution to European security through NATO and the EU. Instead of maligning the country, other Europeans should work with Belgium to overcome the EU's mutually reinforcing crises and to ensure the survival of its major accomplishments, including the Schengen open internal borders system and the single European currency, the euro.

Nu belangrijker dan ooit: steun kwaliteitsjournalistiek.

Neem een abonnement op De Morgen

Op alle artikelen, foto's en video's op rust auteursrecht. Deeplinken kan, maar dan zonder dat onze content in een nieuw frame op uw website verschijnt. Graag enkel de titel van onze website en de titel van het artikel vermelden in de link. Indien u teksten, foto's of video's op een andere manier wenst over te nemen, mail dan naar
DPG Media nv – Mediaplein 1, 2018 Antwerpen – RPR Antwerpen nr. 0432.306.234